Cincinnati Police Chief Teresa Theetge is under fire after telling residents to “learn how to behave” following a violent night that saw five people shot in less than eight hours.
The string of shootings began around 6:30 p.m. Monday near Westknolls Lane and Orland Avenue, where a male victim was killed.
Authorities are searching for a blue Tesla believed to be connected to the incident.
Roughly an hour later, a separate shooting erupted at CityBird restaurant in Fountain Square, injuring two people: a 17-year-old boy grazed on the leg and an adult man shot in the thigh.
Police detained two individuals in connection with the Fountain Square incident, and both victims are expected to recover.
Later that night, another man was shot near the Stanley Rowe Tower Apartments but managed to reach a nearby fire station for help.
The Post Millennial reports that a fifth victim was hospitalized following a separate shooting, as investigators continue to examine all events.
In a public statement, Theetge warned downtown residents that minor disputes can escalate into deadly situations.
“These things sometimes start as a minor altercation and then evolve into something bigger. So do not come downtown, especially on Fountain Square, if you don’t know how to behave,” she said.
The chief’s remarks follow a high-profile mob attack over the summer that put Cincinnati in the national spotlight.
Video footage showed a group of black individuals assaulting two white victims, including a woman who was knocked unconscious after being punched in the face by a man.
The incident sparked intense discussion about crime, race and policing in the city, providing context for Theetge’s recent warning.
Social media users quickly criticized her comments, arguing they appeared to target residents rather than offenders, generating widespread online ridicule.
“Wow, I think she just solved Cincinnati’s crime problem,” wrote Trending Politics co-owner Collin Rugg.
“They should sit in a corner and reflect on their actions. No dessert after dinner,” joked another.
“Criminals have no choice but to comply! She told them to behave with the appropriate hat tilt and everything,” added one commenter.
Theetge later defended her department, emphasizing how viral coverage and online commentary can amplify public perception and misrepresent law enforcement efforts.
The Cincinnati Police Department is also facing internal challenges.
Resist the Mainstream previously reported that senior officers filed lawsuits alleging discrimination against white males, compounding scrutiny on leadership amid rising public concern.
Residents have expressed frustration over downtown safety, highlighting the difficulty of maintaining order in crowded urban areas where minor disputes can quickly escalate.
Analysts say Monday’s shootings underscore broader challenges for law enforcement in Cincinnati: balancing public trust with proactive policing, maintaining safety in high-traffic neighborhoods and intervening in potentially volatile situations before violence escalates.
City leaders are under pressure to restore confidence while addressing root causes of crime.
Theetge’s warning conveyed a tone more reminiscent of a concerned parent than a law enforcement directive, urging residents to “learn how to behave” rather than focusing exclusively on the perpetrators.
Critics quickly highlighted the unusual approach, suggesting it downplayed the severity of the violence.
As authorities continue investigating Monday’s shootings, officials emphasize that maintaining public safety requires a combination of vigilant policing and community cooperation.
Cincinnati’s ongoing challenges with crime remain a central concern for both local leaders and the broader public.
WATCH:
