• About
  • Team
  • Contact
  • Editorial Standards
  • Core Values
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Affiliate Disclosure
Resist the Mainstream
No Result
View All Result
STORE
  • Politics
  • US
  • Media Watch
  • World
  • COVID
  • Story of Hope
  • Opinion
    • Cartoons
NEWSLETTER
Get Ad-Free Login Manage Account
  • Politics
  • US
  • Media Watch
  • World
  • COVID
  • Story of Hope
  • Opinion
    • Cartoons
No Result
View All Result
Resist the Mainstream
No Result
View All Result

Judge Rules Georgia Officials Must Testify in Trump Investigation

Tony Gray by Tony Gray
July 8, 2022 - Updated on July 9, 2022
0

RELATED

Video: Girl Straddled by Drag Queen Sparks Outrage at North Carolina School

Watch: Candace Owens Spars With Professor on Affirmative Action in Feisty ‘Dr. Phil’ Appearance: ‘I’m Giving You Actual Facts’

A Georgia Superior Court judge Wednesday denied a motion by two legislators to have grand jury subpoenas against them quashed.

ADVERTISEMENTS
ON
OFF

Lieutenant Governor Geoff Duncan and former state Senator William Ligon claimed legislative immunity granted under Georgia’s state constitution. The relevant constitutional language reads:

Advertisements

“No member shall be liable to answer in any other place for anything spoken in either house or in any committee meeting of either house.”

Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney agreed, up to a point.

“First, neither the District Attorney nor the grand jurors may ask either witness about anything he said while  participating in any session of the legislature, be that on the floor of the body or in a subcommittee,” McBurney declared. He added that protection extends to spoken words, memos, draft bills and any other written documents prepared by a legislator or staff.

The judge prohibited grand jurors asking about what was said or written but also — perhaps more importantly —  why something was communicated.

“The motivations of the elected officials for the actions they took (or failed to take) during legislative sessions are
not subject to scrutiny by this grand jury (or any other),” explained McBurney.

McBurney added that neither witness may be asked about direct communications he had with any other
legislator in preparing for any session or drafting any legislation or official report. But, he noted, there are limits.

Advertisements

The judge argued there is no “senator-constituent” privilege,  especially when those communications are relevant to possible third-party crimes. In other words, if the the legislator is not the target of an investigation, they must answer grand juror’s questions.

Public disclosure of who meets with legislative decision-makers benefits society because it lets voters  understand who is trying to influence their legislative representatives, the judge explained.

Lobbyists, or other private citizens and organizations, do not create legislation, McBurney remarked, noting they are not elected representatives. “They may — and very often do — submit draft proposals, offer research, and contribute generously to re-election campaigns,” he wrote in his ruling. “But what they may not do is actually conduct the business of the legislature: the speaking, the debating, and, ultimately, the voting.”

He reasoned that people who do not create legislation may not claim legislative immunity. Then, he gave an example of the type of allowed questioning.

“For example, the District Attorney may ask former Senator Ligon to identify any non-legislators with whom he met to discuss ideas such as “rescinding” the certification of the general election and substituting “proper” electors for those already selected,” the judge remarked, but only “if those topics are relevant to the grand
jury’s investigation of possible electoral crimes.”

Senator Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., said he plans to fight his subpoena from the Fulton County district attorney but that legal challenge would take place out of Georgia, according to an Axios report.

Scroll down to leave a comment and share your thoughts.

TRENDING TODAY

Photos Reveal Inside of Nashville Shooter Audrey Hale’s House
US

Photos Reveal Inside of Nashville Shooter Audrey Hale’s House

by RTM Staff
March 29, 2023
Police Chief Reveals Nashville Shooter Audrey Hale Had Another Target in Mind
US

Police Chief Reveals Nashville Shooter Audrey Hale Had Another Target in Mind

by RTM Staff
March 29, 2023


© 2023 Resist the Mainstream

Get Ad-Free Login Manage Account
No Result
View All Result
  • Newsletter
  • Store
  • Politics
  • US
  • Media Watch
  • World
  • COVID
  • Story of Hope
  • Opinion
    • Cartoons
  • About
  • Team
  • Contact
  • Editorial Standards
  • Core Values
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Affiliate Disclosure

© 2023 Resist the Mainstream